One-on-One Conversations • Practice Drill
Coaching an Engineer Shipping Unverified AI-Generated Pull Requests
Moderate Difficulty10 minYour Role: Engineering Team Lead
Conversation Objective
Separate AI tooling adoption from author verification ownership; establish clear pre-review invariants without sounding anti-AI or shaming; align on DORA reliability over raw PR volume.
Workplace Scenario & Dynamics
You are stepping into a 1-on-1 with Devon Park after senior reviewers flagged three consecutive AI-assisted pull requests for subtle runtime and auth gaps.
Devon has been celebrated for shipping 14 pull requests this sprint using AI coding assistants. All happy-path unit tests passed CI, yet three recent PRs introduced an unverified SDK option, a missing authorization guard, and duplicated state logic—shifting heavy verification work onto senior reviewers and raising change failure rate.
Realistic Pushback to Expect
Your counterpart will test your communication and composure. Expect reactions like:
“I shipped 14 pull requests this sprint and every one of them passed CI. Are you saying you want me to stop using AI assistants?”
“If I stop to audit every generated line manually, my ticket velocity drops by half.”
“Isn't catching edge cases what code review is for?”
What Good Looks Like in This Conversation
1. Diagnose FirstUnpack their mindset and constraints before prescribing fixes.
2. Clear BoundariesFrame standards with empathy without taking on their job.
3. Mutual OwnershipAgree on concrete next steps and check-in timeline.
Suggested Opening Angle
You can type your own opening or start with this suggested angle in the simulator:
"Devon, thanks for making time. Your delivery pace has been strong this sprint, and I want to align on how we verify AI-drafted code before it hits review."
Competencies:#coaching#1on1s#code-review#ai-workflows#reliability#Direct#Constructive#Calm#Analytical
Conversation Partner
Devon Park
PersonaMid-Senior Product Engineer protective of AI-assisted coding velocity
Stance: defensive
Private Practice Instant Scorecard
Expensing through your team?Employer Pitch Template