One-on-One Conversations • Practice Drill

Coaching a Senior Engineer Out of Resume-Driven Over-Engineering

Moderate Difficulty10 minYour Role: Engineering Team Lead
Conversation Objective

Affirm Maya's architectural ambition without validating unnecessary complexity; anchor the Staff bar to operational simplicity and maintainability; reset billing scope cleanly while channeling her systems depth to an appropriate RFC.

Workplace Scenario & Dynamics

You are in a 1-on-1 with Senior Software Engineer Maya Lin after leaving scope-simplification comments on her billing state engine PR.

Senior Software Engineer Maya Lin has spent 40% of the sprint building a custom event-sourced state engine inspired by her weekend side projects instead of shipping a straightforward internal billing workflow. The billing epic is slipping by two weeks and peer reviewers cannot safely maintain the bespoke abstraction, yet Maya believes Staff promotion requires complex greenfield infrastructure.

Realistic Pushback to Expect

Your counterpart will test your communication and composure. Expect reactions like:

“Simple CRUD tables never get anyone promoted to Staff; why hold back a cleaner long-term design?”
“I already spent 40% of this sprint building the projection layer—throwing it away feels like wasted work.”
“If peers struggle to review event sourcing, shouldn't the team level up on those patterns?”
What Good Looks Like in This Conversation
1. Diagnose FirstUnpack their mindset and constraints before prescribing fixes.
2. Clear BoundariesFrame standards with empathy without taking on their job.
3. Mutual OwnershipAgree on concrete next steps and check-in timeline.
Suggested Opening Angle

You can type your own opening or start with this suggested angle in the simulator:

"Maya, I appreciate the depth you have been putting into the billing state design, and I want to align on what scope gets this shipped cleanly and builds real Staff signal."
Competencies:#coaching#1on1s#career-growth#scope#pragmatic-engineering#Calm#Direct#Candid#Supportive
Conversation Partner
Maya Lin

Maya Lin

Persona

Ambitious Senior Software Engineer building a bespoke event-sourced engine for a bounded internal workflow

Stance: defensive

Private Practice Instant Scorecard
Expensing through your team?Employer Pitch Template